— Menu & prices
Everything we bake, and what it costs
Traditional Treats
$1.00 each · $12 a dozen
- Carrot Cookie
- Chocolate Chip
- Coconut Macaroons
- Ginger Crinkle (Nov-Feb)
- Kiss Cookie
- M & M Cookie
- Maggie's Mistakes
- Mexican Wedding
- Oatmeal Chewie
- Oatmeal Raisin
- Peanut Butter
- Raspberry Thumbprint
- Sand Tart
- Snickerdoodle
- Sugar
Gourmet Delights
$1.00 each · $12 a dozen
- Billy Goat
- Butterfinger
- Candy Bar
- Gourmet Chocolate Chip
- No Bakes
- Nutty Chocolate Chip
- Peanut Butter Chunk
- Peanut Butter Nobake
- Rice Krispie Treats
- Smiley Face Cookie
- Tahiti Treats (June-Sept)
- Triple Chocolate Sin
- White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Bars & Brownies
By the piece or dozen
German Chocolate
$3.00 · $36/dz
Fudge Brownie
$3.00 · $36/dz
Lemon Bar
$3.00 · $36/dz
Magic Cookie Bar
$3.00 · $36/dz
Rocky Road Brownie
$3.00 · $36/dz
Cream Cheese Brownie
$3.50 · $42/dz
Big Cookies
12" · feeds 8-12
Traditional Treats big cookie
$22
Gourmet Delights big cookie
$25
Celebration Trays
From $44
3.5 dozen tray
$44
4.5 dozen tray
$58
6.5 dozen tray
$82
7.5 dozen tray
$92
8 dozen tray
$98
Decorated Cookies
Prices vary by size and detail
Seasonal Favorites
Changes with the season
Pumpkin Bars
Nov
Oatmeal Cream Pies
Fall
Jam Thumbprints
Dec
Spritz Cookies
Holidays
Roll-N-Cut shapes
All year
How to Order
Three easy ways
- Walk in: case cookies, bars and trays need no notice
- Online: pickup or delivery through DoorDash
- Decorated and custom orders: 2 days' notice
- No Bakes big cookies: 48 hours' notice
— Good to know
Coming up at Maggie's
Decorated cookies need 2 days' notice. Regular cookies need no notice at all!
Pumpkin Bars are back!
Nov 2 - Nov 30
Our Pumpkin Bars are back, and they’re only here in November! Orders start now, so get yours while they last.
$3.50 for a square and $42 for the whole pan! 🧡
Three easy ways to get them:
- Stop by the shop on Prince Street
- Order online for pickup or delivery
- Call us at (501) 336-9600
Planning for Thanksgiving? Order early. We close the Wednesday before Thanksgiving and reopen the following Monday.
Last day for decorated cookie orders
No decorated orders after today until the new year.
Last day before Thanksgiving
Get your Thanksgiving cookies and pumpkin bars early!
Closed for Thanksgiving
Happy Thanksgiving! We reopen Monday, November 30.
Specialty Christmas cookies begin
Christmas celebration trays and holiday cookies are here.
Last day open for the holidays
Get your Christmas orders in early. We usually reopen January 6.