Skip to main content

Maggie's Original Cookie Company

Mon 9-6 · Tue-Fri 7:30-6 · Sat 9-3 · Sun closedSpecials & events →
Custom

— Made just for you

Decorated & custom orders

You name it and we can most likely do it! Birthdays, showers, weddings, teams and businesses.
Ideas

— What we make

Something for every occasion

Baby shower decorated cookies made to order by Maggie's in Conway, AR

Decorated cookies

Your colors, shapes, names and themes. Priced by size and detail.
Personalized birthday cookies from Maggie's Original Cookie Company

Big Cookies

12″ cookie cake with fudge icing and sprinkles. $22 or $25.
Party dessert spread with decorated cookies, brownies and treats from Maggie's in Conway, AR

Celebration Trays

3.5 to 8 dozen of our favorites, $44 to $98.
Gallery

— Recent custom orders

Made for our customers

A few of the decorated sets we’ve made lately. Tap a photo to see it bigger.
A little cutie baby shower
Pastel floral hearts
Two cutie pies for twins
Engagement rings and florals
Winter baby shower
The apple of our eye
Order

— How it works

Three easy steps

Please give us 2 days’ notice. Busy holidays fill up fast, so check our calendar for order cutoffs.

Request a custom order

We reply within one business day.